India@70

Reshaping diets, speeches and even our thoughts

9/2/2017 6:33:04 PM
written By : Shobhaa De Print

Let’s start with what happened at a madrassa on Independence Day this year. Little boys and girls, neatly dressed and holding paper flags, were seated on a dhurrie, when a reporter strolled in. Mistaking the journalist for a government officer, sent to ‘check’ and report to headquarters, the madrassa teacher hastily assured the hack everything was on track. “The children have just finished singing the national anthem…but they will sing it again for you if you want, sir.” What a telling moment! Doesn’t that innocent reaction say everything? To me, this incident was far more revealing of the sentiments across the country than the superb interview of Hamid Ansari, and the censored television address of Tripura CM Manik Sarkar. Taken as a whole, these unconnected but significant incidents point to just one thing: Paranoia, and a lack of trust. As Hamid Ansari stated, “Overall, the very fact that the Indianness of any citizen is being questioned is a disturbing thought.”

Narendra Modi may have been extra considerate this year, when he made the shortest (56 minutes) Independence Day speech from the ramparts of the Red Fort. As expected, it was peppered with the usual alliterations, and word play with the rather trite ‘golis’ and ‘gaalis’ reference. There was little by way of content to reassure citizens when exactly the elusive ‘acche din’ will finally arrive — if they exist at all. Just a few days earlier, Hamid Ansari had spoken up boldly during an impassioned parting interview, in which he’d gone ahead and addressed the herd of elephants in India’s room. There was shock, awe and admiration when he candidly talked about the “sense of unease among Muslims”, and referred to “a sense of insecurity creeping in”. Was he lying? Exaggerating? Over-dramatising? Of course not! He had hit the bull’s eye. If the underlying truth in what he said didn’t make us flinch, it should have. The Prime Minister had two choices once Ansari’s interview gained momentum: A) He could have ignored Ansari. B) Or, Modi could have equally boldly stated it was time to address these prickly issues head on, since they perturb over 184 million Muslim citizens of India. He did neither. Instead, he picked a third, and very shabby option: he not only mocked the erudite gentleman who had been India’s respected Vice President for two terms (2007-2017) by saying that he had shown his true colours (read: Muslim identity) and advised him to “follow your basic ideology and instinct.” If this is not provocative and divisive, what is? To make it worse, the BJP dubbed Ansari a “mannerless” man.

Chief Minister Manik Sarkar publicly stated his position (outrage!) after being asked to ‘reshape’ his Independence Day speech. That word ‘reshape’ is dangerous and loaded. Today, an elected chief minister of an important, sensitive state is being asked to ‘reshape’ a pre-recorded speech which was found unacceptable by Big Brother (Prasar Bharati). What chance do ordinary citizens have? We will soon be ordered — perhaps at gunpoint — to ‘reshape’ our words, thoughts, even emotions. Our diets have already been ‘reshaped’. This is perhaps the first time in 70 years that a chief minister’s speech has been targeted. Surely, citizens have the right to hear it, regardless of what the Centre feels? Hamid Ansari raised the very pertinent Muslim issue of identity and belonging in today’s India, while Manik Sarkar pointed out that Dalits and minorities are under attack. Are they making it up?

These are but two intelligent, educated, aware men daring to voice what countless citizens fear. Ansari has already withdrawn into a neutral zone after the Prime Minister’s below-the-belt tongue lashing. Let’s see what happens to Manik Sarkar, who has openly accused the Central Government of censorship. When asked what action he planned to take, he answered soberly and thoughtfully, “I have brought this to the notice of the common people of our country. They are the best ones to judge what is going on.”

1 comment for “India@70”

  1. yangping55
    Posted Friday, November 3, 2017 at 2:22:37 PM

    michael kors uk


    michael kors outlet


    pandora outlet


    uggs


    burberry outlet


    cheap ugg boots


    coach factory outlet


    ugg outlet online


    canada goose outlet


    air jordans


    coach outlet


    adidas yeezy


    moncler outlet


    ugg slippers


    ugg sandals


    adidas superstar


    polo ralph lauren outlet


    mlb jerseys cheap


    yeezy boost 350


    canada goose jackets


    nmd shoes


    cheap jordans


    burberry sale


    polo outlet


    coach factory outlet


    polo outlet


    moncler outlet


    ugg


    uggs


    michael kors outlet


    pandora outlet


    adidas yeezy boost


    canada goose outlet


    canada goose jackets


    louis vuitton


    mulberry uk


    longchamp outlet


    ugg canada


    pandora jewelry


    ugg boots


    michael kors handbags


    coach outlet store


    cheap uggs


    nmd adidas


    columbia sportswear


    coach outlet


    ugg australia


    christian louboutin outlet


    adidas nmd


    air jordans


    coach outlet


    ugg outlet


    moncler jackets


    polo ralph lauren outlet online


    moncler uk


    ugg outlet


    nike cortez


    hermes handbags


    uggs outlet


    michael kors outlet


    cheap jordans for sale


    hermes bags


    pandora charms sale


    uggs on sale


    jordan retro 11


    oakley sunglasses


    christian louboutin


    jordan shoes


    ugg shoes


    michael kors outlet store


    canada goose coats


    longchamp handbags


    ugg outlet


    moncler uk


    cheap mlb jerseys


    cheap ray ban sunglasses


    ralph lauren outlet


    nfl jerseys wholesale


    coach outlet


    supreme new york


    nike air max


    uggs outlet


    canada goose outlet


    north face outlet


    coach outlet store


    canada goose uk


    coach outlet


    ugg outlet


    ugg australia


    timberland boots


    coach factory outlet


    ugg outlet


    coach outlet


    ugg boots


    michael kors factory outlet


    canada goose jackets


    canada goose coats


    jordan shoes


    ralph lauren sale clearance


    cheap uggs


    polo ralph lauren


    coach outlet


    adidas yeezy


    uggs sale


    pandora jewelry


    canada goose jackets


    coach outlet


    michael kors outlet


    pandora jewelry


    harden vol 1


    coach factory outlet


    adidas superstar


    coach outlet store


    ugg boots for women


    ray ban sunglasses


    hermes outlet


    kate spade handbag


    pandora outlet


    longchamp outlet online


    michael kors canada


    timberland outlet


    canada goose outlet


    kate spade outlet


    jordans


    nike shoes


    air jordan shoes


    michael kors outlet


    uggs canada


    canada goose jackets


    moncler jackets


    yeezy 350 boost


    kate spade


    cheap jordan shoes


    canada goose


    cheap jordans


    cheap nfl jerseys


    moncler coats


    uggs outlet


    nike outlet


    north face outlet


    adidas shoes


    ray ban sunglasses discount


    coach factory outlet


    uggs canada


    coach factory outlet


    pandora jewelry


    ralph lauren outlet


    nike air max


    ugg outlet


    coach outlet


    hermes birkin


    gucci handbags


    polo ralph lauren


    toms shoes


    ray ban sunglasses


    canada goose sale


    ugg boots


    fred perry


    uggs clearance


    kate spade


    cheap jordans


    coach factory outlet online


    canada goose jackets


    cheap jordans


    tory burch outlet store


    air jordan shoes


    moncler jackets


    canada goose jackets


    coach outlet


    michael kors canada


    yeezy boost


    ugg outlet


    polo ralph lauren outlet


    adidas nmd


    nike shoes


    christian louboutin


    canada goose jackets


    christian louboutin outlet


    james harden shoes


    ugg outlet online


    canada goose jackets


    coach factory outlet


    ugg outlet


    coach factory outlet


    cheap jerseys from china


    ugg outlet


    ray ban sunglasses


    ugg boots canada


    ugg boots


    salvatore ferragamo shoes


    moncler outlet


    moncler outlet


    nike outlet online


    adidas outlet


    pandora charms sale clearance


    louis vuitton outlet


    red bottoms shoes


    louis vuitton outlet online


    moncler jackets


    adidas yeezy


    coach outlet


    ugg outlet store


    michael kors outlet


    north face outlet online


    ralph lauren outlet online


    ugg outlet


    pandora jewelry


    ugg boots outlet


    ugg boots on sale


    canada goose clothing


    coach factory outlet online


    burberry outlet


    tory burch outlet


    louboutin shoes


    hermes handbags


    ralph lauren uk


    ugg boots on sale


    ugg ustralia


    coach outlet


    adidas yeezy boost


    fitflops sale


    uggs clearance


    cheap jordans


    discount oakley sunglasses


    michael kors handbags


    canada goose outlet


    pandora charms


    louis vuitton outlet


    yeezy boost


    michael kors outlet online


    jordan retro


    toms shoes outlet


    longchamp uk


    salvatore ferragamo


    canada goose outlet


    ralph lauren uk


    cheap uggs


    canada goose jackets


    yeezy boost


    coach factory outlet


    north face jackets


    red bottoms


    ugg outlet


    pandora jewelry


    burberry


    canada goose


    ray ban sunglasses


    pandora charms


    canada goose jackets


    nike shoes


    coach outlet store online clearances


    ugg boots


    ralph lauren uk


    ralph lauren outlet


    ultra boost


    tory burch outlet


    canada goose clothing


    michael kors outlet online


    nike shoes for men


    canada goose sale


    ugg boots


    ugg sale


    moncler


    air max 2018


    kate spade outlet store


    ralph lauren outlet


    oakley sunglasses


    coach outlet


    canada goose outlet


    uggs outlet


    louis vuitton outlet


    ralph lauren uk


    mbt shoes


    coach outlet


    adidas outlet


    christian louboutin outlet


    canada goose sale


    birkenstock sandals


    supreme clothing


    coach outlet store


    ugg boots


    ray ban sunglasses


    louis vuitton outlet store


    burberry outlet canada


    moncler jackets


    cheap ray ban sunglasses


    michael kors outlet


    coach outlet online


    hermens bags


    ralph lauren sale clearance


    polo ralph lauren outlet online


    canada goose outlet


    cat boots


    michael kors outlet clearance


    ugg boots


    coach outlet


    moncler outlet


    canada goose sale


    birkenstocks


    pandora uk


    kate spade outlet


    burberry outlet


    cheap mlb jerseys


    fitflops


    ugg uk


    nike store


    ugg boots


    coach handbags


    cheap jordans free shipping


    ugg outlet


    birkenstocks


    ugg outlet


    michael kors outlet


    ralph lauren outlet online


    pandora charms


    michael kors outlet


    cheap uggs


    louis vuitton outlet


    michael kors outlet


    nike huarache


    coach outlet


    michael kors handbags


    michael kors outlet clearance


    oakley sunglasses


    hermes handbags


    valentino shoes


    nike outlet store


    cheap ray bans


    oakley sunglasses


    mulberry handbags


    canada goose


    coach outlet store


    coach outlet


    pandora charms sale


    mbt shoes


    michael kors handbags


    ralph lauren outlet


    red bottom shoes


    adidas yeezy


    gucci outlet


    the north face


    ugg boots


    ralph lauren outlet


    canada goose outlet


    coach factorty outlet


    ugg outlet store


    coach factory outlet


    north face jackets


    coach outlet


    ugg outlet


    fred perry polo


    ugg outlet


    ferragamo shoes


    canada goose sale


    cheap oakley sunglasses


    pandora charms sale clearance


    mulberry outlet


    coach factory outlet


    uggs outlet


    coach outlet


    michael kors outlet store


    burberry outlet store


    louboutin shoes


    canada goose


    longchamp handbags


    coach factory outlet


    canada goose outlet


    adidas shoes


    uggs on sale


    ferragamo outlet


    toms shoes outlet


    canada goose


    adidas outlet


    air max 2017


    coach outlet online


    cheap ray ban sunglasses


    ugg outlet


    cheap ray bans


    polo ralph lauren outlet online


    doudoune moncler


    coach canada


    ray ban sunglasses discount


    ugg australia


    polo ralph lauren outlet


    canada goose outlet


    coach factory outlet


    ugg shoes


    coach outlet


    canada goose coats


    christian louboutin


    ralph lauren outlet


    louis vuitton outlet online


    adidas shoes


    nike outlet


    louis vuitton factory outlet


    ugg ustralia


    mulberry bags


    ralph lauren outlet


    michael kors outlet


    uggs clearance


    michael kors outlet


    cheap uggs


    louis vuitton outlet store


    pandora jewelry outlet


    michael kors outlet clearance


    ugg boots


    adidas shoes


    coach outlet


    coach outlet


    ugg outlet


    louboutin shoes


    canada goose outlet


    kate spade bags


    polo ralph lauren


    nike outlet


    ralph lauren outlet


    ugg outlet


    moncler


    coach factory outlet


    moncler jackets outlet


    polo ralph lauren outlet online


    canada goose outlet


    north face jackets


    uggs canada


    adidas nmd


    toms outlet


    valentino shoes outlet


    supreme clothing


    ugg boots


    polo ralph lauren outlet online


    toms outlet


    uggs


    moncler outlet


    coach bags


    coach outlet store online


    ugg boots


    burberry outlet


    coach canada


    nike outlet store


    michael kors handbags


    polo ralph lauren outlet online


    michael kors outlet


    kate spade handbags


    pandora charms


    coach factorty outlet


    north face outlet


    canada goose outlet


    cheap ray ban sunglasses


    pandora


    canadian goose


    north face jackets


    nmd adidas


    toms shoes outlet


    canada goose sale


    burberry outlet


    coach factory outlet


    coach outlet


    ugg boots on sale


    cheap jerseys


    ugg boots


    cheap jordans


    ugg sale


    birkenstock sandals


    christian louboutin outlet


    ralph lauren outlet


    canada goose jackets


    longchamp outlet


    ugg boots


    michael kors outlet store


    polo ralph lauren


    moncler jackets


    ugg boots


    2017.11.3yangping

Leave a comment
 
All Copyrights Reserved @2014 India Se
Engineered by : ZITIMA